Gurteen Knowledge Blog June 30, 2023, 09:31Many people criticize ChatGPT for its potential to harm students’ critical thinking abilities. However, I have a different opinion and believe that it can be a powerful tool to enhance thinking. I plan to write more about this in the future, but for now, in this post ChatGPT: Your critical … Continue reading Chatgpt as a Valuable Thinking Partner ChatGPT and critical thinking
Thinking — or reasoning — involves objectively connecting present beliefs with evidence in order to believe something else. Credit: David T. Moore Books: David T. MooreConnecting Beliefs and Evidence David T. MooreQuotations: David T. MooreConnecting Beliefs and Evidence David T. MooreTags: beliefs (67) | critical thinking (44) | David T. Moore (1) | reasoning (53)Google … Continue reading Connecting Beliefs and Evidence David T. Moore
People can be extremely intelligent, have taken a critical thinking course and know logic inside and out. Yet they may just become clever debaters, not critical thinkers, because they are unwilling to look at their own biases. Credit: Carol Wade Comment: This quote highlights the importance of self-awareness and challenging one’s own biases in order … Continue reading Biases and Critical Thinking Carol Wade
It is lacking in critical thinking to think that studying philosophy will improve your critical thinking. Credit: Nassim Nicholas Taleb Books: Nassim Nicholas TalebPhilosophy and Critical Thinking Nassim Nicholas TalebQuotations: Nassim Nicholas TalebPhilosophy and Critical Thinking Nassim Nicholas TalebTags: critical thinking (44) | Nassim Nicholas Taleb (1) | philosophy (8)Google Web Search Photo Credits: Pixabay (Pixabay)This … Continue reading Philosophy and Critical Thinking Nassim Nicholas Taleb
Gurteen Knowledge Blog October 3, 2023, 13:29From a Knowledge Management perspective, many view chatbots as glorified search engines — tools to look up facts or provide straightforward answers. However, chatbots have the capacity for more conversational interactions to aid complex reasoning and decision-making. In my blook, I am developing a chapter on AI and KM. It … Continue reading Chatbots as an Aid to Critical Thinking Reasoning and decision-making
People want you to think critically until you actually do it. Credit: Chris Meyer Books: Chris MeyerCritical Thinking Paradox Chris MeyerQuotations: Chris MeyerCritical Thinking Paradox Chris MeyerTags: Chris Meyer (1) | critical thinking (44)Google Web Search Photo Credits: Pixabay (Pixabay)This quotation is part of a blook on Conversational Leadership. It is one of many quotations that … Continue reading Critical Thinking Paradox Chris Meyer
Are Smart People Ruining Democracy? | Dan Kahan Posts where this video is embedded Analyze Assumptions and Biases Probe the assumptions and biases that might be embedded in a chatbot’s responses Analyze Logical Fallacies Use the chatbot to analyze logical fallacies Chatbots and Genai in Knowledge Management Chatbots are more than just question/answer machines Chatbots as Critical Thinking Partners … Continue reading Are Smart People Ruining Democracy? Dan Kahan, 2018
By interacting with chatbots in innovative ways that encourage examining issues from different perspctives, we can sharpen our critical thinking skills. Credit: David Gurteen Source: Leveraging Chatbots to Aid Critical Thinking SkillsPosts where this quotation is embedded Analyze Assumptions and Biases Probe the assumptions and biases that might be embedded in a chatbot’s responses Analyze Logical Fallacies … Continue reading Leveraging Chatbots to Aid Critical Thinking Skills David Gurteen
Freethinkers are those who are willing to use their minds without prejudice and without fearing to understand things that clash with their own customs, privileges, or beliefs. This state of mind is not common, but it is essential for critical thinking. Credit: Leo Tolstoy Books: Leo TolstoyFreethinkers’ Mindset Leo TolstoyQuotations: Leo TolstoyFreethinkers’ Mindset Leo TolstoyTags: … Continue reading Freethinkers’ Mindset Leo Tolstoy
The goal is to use chatbots to supplement, not replace, human critical thinking and evaluation. Credit: David Gurteen Source: Leveraging Chatbots to Aid Critical Thinking SkillsPosts where this quotation is embedded Analyze Assumptions and Biases Probe the assumptions and biases that might be embedded in a chatbot’s responses Analyze Logical Fallacies Use the chatbot to analyze logical … Continue reading Chatbots Should Supplement Not Replace Human Critical Thinking David Gurteen
Do not indoctrinate your children. Teach them how to think for themselves, how to evaluate evidence, and how to disagree with you. Credit: Richard Dawkins Books: Richard DawkinsTeaching Critical Thinking Richard DawkinsQuotations: Richard DawkinsTeaching Critical Thinking Richard DawkinsTags: critical thinking (44) | Richard Dawkins (1)Google Web Search Photo Credits: Pixabay (Pixabay)This quotation is part of a … Continue reading Teaching Critical Thinking Richard Dawkins
While immensely capable, chatbots have significant limitations compared to human cognition. They lack nuanced communication skills, grounded world knowledge, critical thinking, and sound judgment. Credit: David Gurteen Source: Limitations of ChatbotsPosts where this quotation is embedded Analyze Assumptions and Biases Probe the assumptions and biases that might be embedded in a chatbot’s responses Analyze Logical Fallacies Use … Continue reading Chatbots Lack Nuanced Communication Skills David Gurteen
Gurteen Knowledge Blog July 3, 2024, 07:34People are reading less and understanding less of what they read, which is a societal problem. Social media and short online content make it hard to focus on longer, more complex writing. We often skim articles instead of reading them carefully, which makes it hard to understand complex ideas and … Continue reading The Decline of Reading We need to enhance reading comprehension skills
We are drowning in information, while starving for wisdom. The world henceforth will be run by synthesizers, people able to put together the right information at the right time, think critically about it, and make important choices wisely. Credit: E. O. Wilson Posts where this quotation is embedded Analyze Assumptions and Biases Probe the assumptions and … Continue reading We Are Drowning in Information, While Starving for Wisdom E. O. Wilson
Gurteen Knowledge Blog January 28, 2024, 20:15“Extraordinary claims need extraordinary proof,” a saying often credited to Carl Sagan, highlights a fundamental scientific and critical thinking principle. It means that if someone makes an unlikely or unusual claim, they need solid and convincing evidence to support it. Such claims, which go against what is typically accepted or … Continue reading Extraordinary Claims Need Extraordinary Proof The Carl Sagan Standard
Gurteen Knowledge Blog July 21, 2024, 21:52In a captivating YouTube conversation, Peter Boghossian and Will Reusch discuss the importance of critical thinking for nurturing curiosity, challenging assumptions, and stimulating intellectual humility. They also discuss various educational techniques, including Socratic questioning and practical experiments, highlighting how these methods encourage openness to new ideas and rational discourse. Reusch, … Continue reading Critical Thinking’s Role in Nurturing Curiosity A conversation between Peter Boghossian and Will Reusch
Please stop saying you researched it. You didn’t research anything and it is highly probable you don’t know how to do so. Did you compile a literature review and write abstracts on each article? Or better yet, did you collect a random sample of sources and perform independent probability statistics on the reported results? No? … Continue reading Please Stop Saying You Researched It Linda Gamble Spadaro
Teaching critical thinking alone is not a solution to helping people question their beliefs, it simply helps them to better post rationalize their beliefs. Credit: David Gurteen People: David GurteenDavid Gurteen Keynote speaker, writer and conversational facilitatorBooks: David GurteenA Conversation Architect Designs Strategic Conversations David GurteenAPM Conference: Conversational Leadership David Gurteen (2016)Being Truthful Versus Telling … Continue reading Teaching Critical Thinking Alone Is Not a Solution to Helping People Question Their Beliefs David Gurteen
Gurteen Knowledge Blog July 25, 2024, 08:59GenAI’s potential negative impact on critical thinking deserves our attention. A recent post in my blook looks at the Myth of Thamus and Theuth, a cautionary tale from Plato’s Phaedrus, to draw parallels with today’s advancements in AI. Like Socrates, who questioned the invention of writing for its effect on … Continue reading The Myth of Thamus and Theuth in the Age of AI Does GenAI harm our critical thinking skills?
In this book, Red Teaming, Bryce Hoffman shows how the most innovative and disruptive companies, such as Google and Toyota, employ Red Teaming techniques. A red team is a team that is formed with the objective of subjecting an organization’s plans, programmes, ideas, and assumptions to rigorous analysis and challenge. He also shows how many … Continue reading Red Teaming: How Your Business Can Conquer the Competition by Challenging Everything by Bryce G. Hoffman (2017)
This talk by Peter Boghossian at The Ramsay Centre for Western Civilisation explores the applicability and significance of the Socratic method in fostering critical thinking and advancing civilization. Peter begins by highlighting his interest in finding simple, conceptual “bales of hay” to clean up cognitive processes, inspired by a childhood lesson from his father on … Continue reading The Socratic Method in the Western Tradition Peter Boghossian (2023)
Gurteen Knowledge Blog December 5, 2021, 11:18Jordan Peterson recently tweeted: The best way to teach people critical thinking is to teach them to write because there’s no difference between that and thinking. Credit: Jordan Peterson I would disagree that there is no difference, but writing certainly forces me to assess my ideas critically. When I write … Continue reading Writing Aids Critical Thinking What’s the difference between writing and critical thinking?
Gurteen Knowledge Blog October 23, 2024, 09:44Chatbots can be powerful tools for developing our critical thinking skills, especially when exploring different perspectives. One effective approach is to ask the chatbot to play “Devil’s Advocate,” allowing it to present counterarguments or alternative viewpoints. Doing this encourages us to look at an issue from multiple angles, deepening our … Continue reading Enhancing Critical Thinking Using chatbots to explore new perspectives and deepen understanding
Perhaps the essence of the Liberal outlook could be summed up in a new decalogue, not intended to replace the old one but only to supplement it. The Ten Commandments that, as a teacher, I should wish to promulgate, might be set forth as follows: Do not feel absolutely certain of anything. Do not think … Continue reading Bertrand Russell’s Ten Commandments for Critical Thinking Bertrand Russell
Gurteen Knowledge Blog December 1, 2024, 17:00I will be giving a talk titled Chatbots as Critical Thinking Partners at the AI Challenges & Adaptations Conference, hosted by the Bibliotheca Alexandrina, on Tuesday, December 3rd. While I would love to attend in person, my presentation will be delivered via a pre-recorded video. To clarify, I’m not a … Continue reading Chatbots as Critical Thinking Partners Talk at the AI Challenges & Adaptations Conference, hosted by the Bibliotheca Alexandrina
This is a pre-recorded video of a talk titled “Chatbots as Critical Thinking Partners” that I presented at the AI Challenges & Adaptations Conference hosted by the Bibliotheca Alexandrina on Tuesday, December 3, 2024. You can find the ideas behind my talk in the chapter of my blook, Chatbots as Critical Thinking Partners. Posts where … Continue reading Chatbots as Critical Thinking Partners – Talk for Bibliotheca Alexandrina David Gurteen (2024)
Gurteen Knowledge Blog June 30, 2023, 10:15I sometimes have conversations with people who don’t know much about a topic I’ve studied in depth. However, they still hold strong opinions about it and have a clear narrative to support their viewpoint. We are all susceptible to this phenomenon, but what is its underlying mechanism? We often encounter … Continue reading How We Construct Our Unfounded Beliefs And false narratives
The Fallibility of Science The Scientific Method for Everyday Life Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter The scientific method has evolved to solve problems through rigorous inquiry. Facing global issues requires clear, evidence-based approaches. Historical insights into this method can help guide our complex decision-making today. The development of the scientific method—a systematic approach … Continue reading The Roots of the Scientific Method Exploring the history of the scientific method
Recognising New Age Mumbo Jumbo The History of the Socratic Method Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter The Socratic method uses dialogue to stimulate critical thinking and challenge assumptions, aligning closely with the principles of Conversational Leadership. Through probing questions, it encourages open conversation, helping to develop a deeper understanding and intellectual humility. This … Continue reading The Socratic Method A powerful tool for critical thinking
The Socratic Elenchus The Two Pillars of Truth Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter Conversational Leadership emphasizes the importance of intellectual humility and open-mindedness in discussions. Polarization and confirmation bias can stifle productive conversations on complex issues. By asking, “How could you or I be wrong?” we foster self-reflection, critical thinking, and openness to … Continue reading How Could We Be Wrong? Is a crucial question to ask in a conversation
The Difference Between Sense-making and Meaning-making What Are Beliefs? Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter If we are to create a better world, we need to make better sense of things and improve the decisions we make, especially when it comes to global issues such as climate change, regional and religious conflict, poverty, and … Continue reading Introduction: Knowledge Delusion We delude ourselves about what we know and how we make decisions
Limitations of Chatbots Why Chatbots Can’t Have Real Human Conversations Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter Like us humans, chatbots are imperfect and prone to errors, biases, and lapses in logic. Rather than downplaying them because of these defects, we should approach chatbots as opportunities to engage in critical thinking. By questioning and verifying … Continue reading Embracing the Imperfections of Chatbots Cultivating critical thinking in the age of AI
Why Chatbots Can’t Have Real Human Conversations Chatbots and Genai in Knowledge Management Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter Chatbots are extremely powerful and multifaceted AI tools with many possible uses. While it is not necessary to understand how chatbots work internally, it is valuable to have a basic understanding of their core functions … Continue reading Uses of Chatbots Practical applications of conversational AI
Chatbots to Analyze Conversations and Presentations Evaluate Sources and Evidence Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter The world faces many intricate challenges that require critical thinking and nuanced analysis. If used creatively, chatbots like ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini can enhance our critical thinking capacities. By interacting with chatbots innovatively, we can sharpen our skills … Continue reading Chatbots as Critical Thinking Partners Stimulating critical thinking is one of the most powerful application of chatbots
Chatbots and Genai in Knowledge Management From Mind to Information – the Role of AI in Knowledge Encoding Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter As AI increasingly shapes our world, we need to consider its effect on critical thinking. The Myth of Thamus and Theuth cautions against overreliance on technology for knowledge. Cultivating human … Continue reading Artificial Intelligence and the Quest for Knowledge Exploring the parallels between Plato’s Phaedrus and the challenges of GenAI
Open Mindedness ** Active Listening ** Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter Critical thinking objectively analyzes, evaluates, and synthesizes information to form a reasoned judgment or decision. It involves using logic and reasoning to examine assumptions, arguments, evidence, and alternative perspectives to arrive at well-informed and justified conclusions. If you can think, and speak, … Continue reading Critical Thinking ** Analyzing information and arguments to make sound judgments and decisions
The Purposes of Conversation Levels of Conversation ** Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter To have a productive conversation, participants must possess several conversational capacities. In two articles, Conversation and Silence, Part One, and Conversations That Matter: What It Takes to Have Them, Dave Pollard lists seven prerequisites or capacities for an effective or real conversation – one … Continue reading Conversational Capacities Prerequisites to a good conversation
How Could We Be Wrong? Conclusion: Two Pillars of Truth Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter The pursuit of truth is a fundamental human endeavor. However, arriving at the truth can be challenging, as our beliefs and ideas may be based on flawed assumptions or lack sufficient evidence. The scientific method and the Socratic … Continue reading The Two Pillars of Truth How the scientific method and Socratic elenchus underpin civilization
The Two Pillars of Truth Introduction: Two Pillars of Truth Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter We need to recognize that the pursuit of truth and the application of rigorous critical thinking are not just intellectual exercises but moral and civic responsibilities. Engaging in open dialogue and thoughtful conversations is crucial in this process, … Continue reading Conclusion: Two Pillars of Truth Critical thinking – a civic duty
Trust & Belief Formation Our Tribal Nature Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter Many false beliefs feel convincing because they rest upon simple, appealing stories. We tend to readily accept uncomplicated narratives without verification. What drives this habit, and how do we overcome it? Why do we accept simple stories? Several intertwined factors make … Continue reading The Allure of Simple Stories We tend to readily accept uncomplicated narratives without verification
Tribal Thinking Discrediting People ** Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter Motivated reasoning is where we look for arguments in favor of conclusions we want to believe, regardless of the evidence. This is a primary stumbling block in forming sound beliefs and making good decisions. However, if we are science-curious, we are more likely … Continue reading Science Curiosity A desire to seek out and consume scientific information for pleasure
Our Most Powerful Technology Is Conversation Our Brains Are Designed for Conversation Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter In Plato’s Phaedrus, Socrates shares the myth of Thamus and Theuth, questioning the invention of writing. Writing, he argues, weakens memory and offers the appearance of wisdom without true understanding. Socrates suggests that serious discourse using … Continue reading The Myth of Thamus and Theuth Does writing allow the pretense of understanding, rather than true understanding?
Speed-conversation Reverse Brainstorming Café Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter We all hold deeply rooted personal beliefs, many of which we have never questioned. Street Epistemology is a conversational technique based on the Socratic method, designed to explore our beliefs and our confidence in them. You can learn more about the method on the … Continue reading Street Epistemology Exploring deeply held beliefs
Oracy What Is the Difference Between Rhetoric and Oracy? Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter Rhetoric is often construed as insincere or meaningless language that sounds clever. This is an unduly negative perspective. Rhetoric is a critical cognitive and communication skill. Introduction Simply put, the purpose of rhetoric is to influence people through speech … Continue reading Rhetoric To influence people through speech or writing