Nurturing an Innovation Culture Allowing emergence, not imposing change

Introduction: Innovation

Silicon Valley Versus Route 128

Nurturing an innovative culture goes beyond traditional management and control methods. Many initiatives fail by trying to enforce change through rigid directives, which can backfire. Instead, culture should be seen as emergent, evolving naturally through interactions, flexibility, and supportive environments where creativity can thrive.

The idea that a culture can be managed into place is widely accepted, but it’s also deeply flawed. Traditional culture change initiatives, laden with communication plans, motivational posters, and re-education programs, often act as superficial responses to deeper issues.

They create an aversion therapy effect, pressuring employees to “change now or face the program” and rarely produce the intended results. At worst, these initiatives can even create resentment, with employees viewing them as hypocritical or insincere efforts to mold behavior in ways determined by leadership rather than nurture authentic growth.

Actual cultural change—and especially the creation of an innovative culture—requires a more nuanced approach that sees culture as an emergent property of interactions, not a set of values that can be dictated. Conversational Leadership plays a key role here, encouraging open, authentic dialogues that help shape culture through shared understanding and collective insights rather than top-down directives.

Culture emerges from an organization’s cumulative interactions, behaviors, and stories. Rather than a top-down directive, an innovative culture develops through adaptive and meaningful connections that evolve over time.

Based on David Snowden’s Cynefin framework, we need to recognize that culture is inherently complex. It can’t be engineered into a predetermined outcome, nor can it be manipulated by outside consultants prescribing one-size-fits-all solutions.

Instead, encouraging innovation means working within the existing culture, allowing it to evolve organically by altering interactions, supporting diverse perspectives, and focusing on real problems rather than idealized goals.

Principles for Cultivating an Innovative Culture

Culture is an Emergent System, Not a Set of Ideals

Culture is not a predefined list of ideals. It’s an emergent system formed by everyday interactions. This complexity means we should avoid prescribing what the culture “should” be. Instead, we should focus on nurturing an environment where diverse ideas and approaches can emerge.

Organizational culture is the attitudes, customs, rituals, values and beliefs shared by the members of an organization that govern their behavior.

Organizational culture is emergent. It is the result of the everyday interactions, behaviors, and conversations by the members of an organization.

Culture is the way that we do things around here that we all understand but we can’t really articulate.

Credit: Dave Snowden

Direct Action Over Platitudes

Rather than announcing aspirational values or attempting to redefine the organization’s narrative, meaningful cultural change comes from direct, observable actions that stimulate new interactions and experiences.

Actions speak louder than words. Those who take intentional, purpose-driven actions to create new stories—especially those that challenge negative patterns—can help shift the culture organically.

Practical Approaches for Encouraging Innovation

Focus on the Real Problems, Not “Culture”

“Culture” often becomes a catch-all term for deeper, specific issues, such as risk aversion or rigid leadership styles. Before declaring a need for culture change, organizations should clarify their goals. For example, if the aim is to become more risk-tolerant or enhance employee collaboration, those specific goals should be the focus. Addressing these underlying issues can naturally foster a more innovative environment without imposing a top-down culture shift.

Use Safe-to-Fail Experiments

Instead of sweeping culture change programs, use safe-to-fail experiments to test new behaviors. These small, low-risk initiatives allow the organization to explore innovative ideas without large-scale disruption.

For instance, if the organization aims to encourage collaboration, it might experiment with cross-departmental projects in which employees work on challenges together. These experiments should be flexible and adaptable based on feedback, helping the organization learn and evolve without forcing predetermined outcomes.

Manage Connections and Interactions

Who interacts with whom in an organization dramatically influences the culture. Conversational Leadership can help guide these interactions by encouraging open, meaningful dialogues across departments, allowing employees to share experiences and ideas that drive cultural shifts. This approach helps create a more connected and collaborative environment that empowers employees to innovate without relying on top-down directives.

Manage Constraints

Overly rigid constraints can stifle innovation, creating workarounds and shadow cultures that resist the prescribed norms. However, completely removing all constraints is also counterproductive. The key is to adjust constraints dynamically, allowing for flexibility where innovation is desired while maintaining structure where stability is essential. We should assess where more freedom is required to explore and where structure might still support effective operations.

Solving Problems Through Indirect Approaches

Sometimes, stimulating innovation requires an indirect approach, as explained in John Kay’s concept of obliquity. This method focuses on tangible issues rather than aiming directly at abstract goals like “changing the culture.” For example, if the goal is to build cross-departmental understanding, an organization might encourage employees from different teams to collaborate on a real-world problem. This practical, problem-focused approach naturally fosters the intended cultural changes without explicitly targeting “cultural change.”

Stimulating a Culture Through Emergence

Ultimately, creating an innovative culture is about enabling emergence rather than imposing structure. Innovation cannot be mandated, and culture cannot be engineered by decree. Instead, we should focus on creating the conditions for creativity to thrive.

This involves changing the nature of interactions, adjusting constraints, and setting the stage for employees to explore, experiment, and adapt in a supportive environment. By taking a more indirect, action-focused approach, organizations can nurture a culture that evolves naturally and embraces innovation as a core value.

In this emergent view, culture is not a goal to be achieved but an evolving pattern to be observed, nurtured, and occasionally nudged. By embracing this complexity and acknowledging the limits of our control, we can create a resilient, adaptive environment that supports innovation without imposing a predefined “ideal culture.”

To build an innovative culture, we should create conditions that allow ideas to emerge naturally. We should encourage open interactions, adjust constraints thoughtfully, and support small, low-risk experiments. By guiding change through these practical actions, we can help develop a culture of creativity and adaptability over time.

Resources

• Blog Post: The myth of managed culture change by Chris Corrigan
• Blog Post: OMG, it’s culture change time by Dave Snowden
• Paper: Designing for Emergence and Innovation: Redesigning Design
• Guide: Creating the Culture for Innovation: Practical Guide for Leaders
• Guide: Thinking Differently: A Practical Guide for Leaders

POST NAVIGATION

Introduction: Innovation

Silicon Valley Versus Route 128

CHAPTER NAVIGATION

Strategy

Motivation and Engagement

Close

Pop-up all Chapters

Tags: complexity (92) | constraints (2) | culture (23) | emergence (11) | innovation (44) | narrative (17) | obliquity (7) | social interaction (8) | storytelling (16) | values (34)

SEARCH