Gurteen Knowledge Blog January 28, 2024, 20:15“Extraordinary claims need extraordinary proof,” a saying often credited to Carl Sagan, highlights a fundamental scientific and critical thinking principle. It means that if someone makes an unlikely or unusual claim, they need solid and convincing evidence to support it. Such claims, which go against what is typically accepted or … Continue reading Extraordinary Claims Need Extraordinary Proof The Carl Sagan Standard
This talk by Peter Boghossian at The Ramsay Centre for Western Civilisation explores the applicability and significance of the Socratic method in fostering critical thinking and advancing civilization. Peter begins by highlighting his interest in finding simple, conceptual “bales of hay” to clean up cognitive processes, inspired by a childhood lesson from his father on … Continue reading The Socratic Method in the Western Tradition Peter Boghossian (2023)
Scientific attitudes are not based on rational evaluation of evidence, and therefore providing information does not change them. Attitudes are determined instead by a host of contextual and cultural factors that make them largely immune to change. Credit: Steven Sloman Source: The Knowledge Illusion (Page 160, hardback edition)Posts where this quotation is embedded Conclusion: Two Pillars … Continue reading Scientific Attitudes Are Not Based on Rational Evaluation of Evidence Steven Sloman
If you are setting out to work in a new field you should thoroughly research that field. Right? Wrong! The traditional view is that you should read all that you can in order to get the base of existing knowledge and then move forward from this. There is a flaw in this argument and it … Continue reading A Flaw in the Scientific Method Edward de Bono
Gurteen Knowledge Blog August 15, 2024, 10:50I smile when I read discussions on social media about evolution where someone dismisses it by saying, “It’s just a theory”, as in doing so, they reveal their misunderstanding of science. In scientific terms, a theory is not simply a guess or a hunch but a well-substantiated explanation based on … Continue reading It’s Just a Theory Understanding scientific terms
Gurteen Knowledge Blog March 12, 2021, 11:26I recently posted this quotation from Edward de Bono in my LinkedIn feed. I’m afraid I have to disagree that it is a flaw in the scientific method. Still, it’s an interesting thought and has had a mixture of comments on LinkedIn, some supporting the view, others disagreeing. Take a … Continue reading A Flaw in the Scientific Method? Edward de Bono
Gurteen Knowledge Blog November 6, 2022, 15:07Carl Sagan was a fantastic scientist. This ominous prediction is taken from his 1995 book The Demon-Haunted World: Science as a Candle in the Dark. I have long felt that although we don’t all need to be scientists, we need to understand the philosophy of science and the scientific method … Continue reading Carl Sagan’s Foreboding on the Future of America in 1995 Science is more than a body of knowledge; it is a way of thinking
1. It is easy to obtain confirmations, or verifications, for nearly every theory–if we look for confirmations. 2. Confirmations should count only if they are the result of risky predictions; that is to say, if, unenlightened by the theory in question, we should have expected an event which was incompatible with the theory–an event which … Continue reading Science as Falsification Karl Popper
Gurteen Knowledge Blog January 19, 2024, 12:14This chapter, The Two Pillars of Truth, from my blook, was inspired by a talk by Peter Boghossian on the Socratic method in the Western tradition. Given my interest in science and cosmology—I have a degree in physics—and my interest in dialogue and how we form our beliefs, it’s unsurprising … Continue reading The Two Pillars of Truth The scientific method and the Socratic elenchus
Conclusion: Two Pillars of Truth The Scientific Method Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter In this chapter, I explore the two foundational pillars of truth-seeking: the scientific method and the Socratic elenchus. The pursuit of truth is not just an intellectual exercise; it is a necessity in an age where science and technology drive … Continue reading Introduction: Two Pillars of Truth The convergence of science and philosophy in the pursuit of knowledge
WikipediaCarl SaganYouTubeCarl SaganGoogleCarl SaganBooks: Carl SaganCarl Sagan American astronomer, planetary scientist, cosmologist, astrophysicist, astrobiologist, author, and science communicator.Carl Sagan – Prophetic Last Interview Carl Sagan (1995)Carl Sagan’s Dragon Carl SaganI Have a Foreboding Carl SaganScience Is a Profound Source of Spirituality Carl SaganSkeptical Interrogation Carl SaganThe Rise of Technical Civilizations Carl SaganQuotations: Carl SaganCarl Sagan’s … Continue reading Carl Sagan American astronomer, planetary scientist, cosmologist, astrophysicist, astrobiologist, author, and science communicator.
Introduction: Two Pillars of Truth The Provisional Nature of Scientific Knowledge Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter Understanding the scientific method is crucial for navigating the complexities of the natural world. Many people struggle with science because they lack a basic grasp of its principles. By learning the scientific method, we can engage with … Continue reading The Scientific Method The backbone of modern science
The Scientific Method Understanding Scientific Terms Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter Scientific knowledge is always open to change and revision. This provisional nature of knowledge can be misunderstood as a flaw in the scientific method, leading to mistrust in scientific findings. Embracing this flexibility is essential, as it enables science to self-correct and … Continue reading The Provisional Nature of Scientific Knowledge Understanding science as an ongoing process
The Provisional Nature of Scientific Knowledge Congruence, Coherence, and Contingent Truth Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter Scientific terms have precise meanings but are often misunderstood outside scientific circles. This confusion frequently leads to misinterpretations of scientific concepts. Understanding these terms helps clarify how scientific knowledge is developed, tested, and validated. When discussing the … Continue reading Understanding Scientific Terms Clarifying common misconceptions
Congruence, Coherence, and Contingent Truth The Roots of the Scientific Method Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter Science aims to uncover the truths of the natural world through careful observation and experimentation. However, it’s essential to acknowledge its limitations, as human biases and errors can influence results. Recognizing science’s fallibility leads to a more … Continue reading The Fallibility of Science Understanding the limits and strengths of science
The Fallibility of Science The Scientific Method for Everyday Life Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter The scientific method has evolved to solve problems through rigorous inquiry. Facing global issues requires clear, evidence-based approaches. Historical insights into this method can help guide our complex decision-making today. The development of the scientific method—a systematic approach … Continue reading The Roots of the Scientific Method Exploring the history of the scientific method
The Roots of the Scientific Method Pseudoscience and Its Dangers Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter Conversational Leadership naturally integrates with the principles of the scientific method, as both emphasize inquiry and dialogue. While the scientific method is often linked to laboratory experiments, its structured approach—observation, hypothesis, and analysis—can enrich our everyday conversations and … Continue reading The Scientific Method for Everyday Life Thinking and decision-making beyond the lab
The Scientific Method for Everyday Life Recognising New Age Mumbo Jumbo Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter Misinformation and disinformation are common on the web, often overshadowing crucial facts. Pseudoscience, in particular, masquerades as legitimate science without proper evidence or methods. It can lead to dangerous consequences, especially in health, undermining public trust in … Continue reading Pseudoscience and Its Dangers Misinformation and its impact on society
Pseudoscience and Its Dangers The Socratic Method Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter Much like pseudoscience, New Age beliefs and practices are widespread and often presented in confusing or meaningless terms, which can mislead people into adopting unproven ideas or ignoring evidence-based solutions. Recognizing the difference between credible information and New Age mumbo jumbo … Continue reading Recognising New Age Mumbo Jumbo Understanding and avoiding deceptive New Age ideas
How Could We Be Wrong? Conclusion: Two Pillars of Truth Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter The pursuit of truth is a fundamental human endeavor. However, arriving at the truth can be challenging, as our beliefs and ideas may be based on flawed assumptions or lack sufficient evidence. The scientific method and the Socratic … Continue reading The Two Pillars of Truth How the scientific method and Socratic elenchus underpin civilization
The Two Pillars of Truth Introduction: Two Pillars of Truth Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter We need to recognize that the pursuit of truth and the application of rigorous critical thinking are not just intellectual exercises but moral and civic responsibilities. Engaging in open dialogue and thoughtful conversations is crucial in this process, … Continue reading Conclusion: Two Pillars of Truth Critical thinking – a civic duty
The DIKW (data, Information, Knowledge, Wisdom) Pyramid Knowledge Only Exists in the Mind Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter There are several ways of attempting to “know something” (acquiring knowledge). Some of them are more reliable than others. There are several “ways of knowing ” or, more strictly, trying to “know something” (acquiring knowledge). … Continue reading Ways of Knowing Ways of acquiring knowledge
The Argumentative Theory of Human Reason Knowledge Is Communal Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter As individuals, we know almost nothing compared to what we think we know. Our individual knowledge is mostly a delusion. We are ignorant of our ignorance. We have built hugely complex societies and technologies through cumulative cultural evolution, but … Continue reading The Knowledge Delusion We know far less than we think we do
The Knowledge Delusion The Extended Mind Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter Most of what we consider our knowledge is an illusion as, in reality, it is distributed in other people’s minds. Knowledge is communal. Knowledge is communal As described in The knowledge delusion, we know almost nothing individually compared to what we think … Continue reading Knowledge Is Communal Most of our knowledge resides in other people
Rethinking Our Beliefs The Allure of Simple Stories Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter What we consider to be our personal knowledge is mostly a delusion. Most of the knowledge we think we own resides in other people’s minds. As I explained in the Knowledge Delusion, we each know very little. What we consider … Continue reading Trust & Belief Formation Trust plays a critical role in forming our beliefs
Tribal Thinking Discrediting People ** Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter Motivated reasoning is where we look for arguments in favor of conclusions we want to believe, regardless of the evidence. This is a primary stumbling block in forming sound beliefs and making good decisions. However, if we are science-curious, we are more likely … Continue reading Science Curiosity A desire to seek out and consume scientific information for pleasure