Gurteen Knowledge Blog June 23, 2021, 18:53The United States’ founding fathers understood the importance of a well-informed citizenry to vote wisely to elect good leaders, as these two quotations clearly show. Today, like so many other democratic nations, not only are citizens not educated in the “science of government,” they do not have the ability to make … Continue reading Has Democracy Outlived Its Usefulness? The best argument against Democracy is a five-minute conversation with the average voter
The best argument against Democracy is a five-minute conversation with the average voter. Credit: Unknown but often misattributed to Winston Churchill Source: This quotation is usually attributed to Winston Churchill but there is no evidence he ever said it.Posts where this quotation is embedded Avoiding Modern-day Colonialism Colonialism: the dominance, control, and exploitation by one group … Continue reading The Best Argument Against Democracy Misattributed to Winston Churchill
Gurteen Knowledge Blog July 1, 2024, 10:10In a year marked by numerous elections worldwide, it is essential to reflect on Socrates’ perspectives on democracy. Socrates held a nuanced view, recognizing that democracy’s theoretical ideals often clash with the reality of citizens’ limited expertise. He observed that the loudest voices frequently overshadow the wisest, leading to decisions … Continue reading Socrates on Democracy Balancing wisdom and governance
Many forms of Government have been tried, and will be tried in this world of sin and woe. No one pretends that democracy is perfect or all-wise. Indeed it has been said that democracy is the worst form of Government except for all those other forms that have been tried from time to time. Credit: … Continue reading Democracy Is Not Perfect Winston Churchill
Democray is a conversation … Modern democracy as we know it, it’s built on top of specific information technology. Once the information technology changes, it’s an open question whether democracy can survive. And the biggest danger now is the opposite of what we faced in the Middle Ages.In the Middle Ages, it was impossible to … Continue reading Democracy Relies on Conversation: Can It Survive the AI Era? Yuval Harari (2023)
Are Smart People Ruining Democracy? | Dan Kahan Posts where this video is embedded Avoiding Modern-day Colonialism Colonialism: the dominance, control, and exploitation by one group over another Conversation in Ancient Greek Society ** Socrates, Plato and Aristotle Deliberative Democracy ** Deliberation is central to decision-making Democracy’s Spectrum ** From Direct to Representative Enlightenment 2.0 A New Enlightenment for the … Continue reading Are Smart People Ruining Democracy? Dan Kahan, 2018
Abstract This paper compares the debate quality in the plenary sessions of an Irish Citizens’ Assembly and an Irish parliamentary committee to assess the epistemic effects of public deliberation on a contentious subject: abortion. The unusual occurrence of a similar process of detailed discussion on the same topic in different institutions at around the same … Continue reading Measuring Epistemic Deliberation on Polarized Issues: the Case of Abortion Provision in Ireland Jane Suiter, David M Farrell , Clodagh Harris and Philip Murphy
Gurteen Knowledge Blog November 23, 2024, 17:51I’ve long believed that democracy should be about more than voting every few years—it’s about how we engage with and improve our communities every day. The Obama Foundation embodies this broader vision, empowering individuals to drive meaningful change in every aspect of their lives. Here is its mission: Our mission … Continue reading Obama Foundation Inspiring, empowering, and connecting people to change their world
video player How can groups make good decisions? | Mariano Sigman and Dan Ariely Mariano closes this talk with the . You can read the transcript below. Partial Transcript Good collective decisions require two components: deliberation and diversity of opinions. Right now, the way we typically make our voice heard in many societies is through … Continue reading How Can Groups Make Good Decisions? Mariano Sigman and Dan Ariely (2017)
Executive Summary Overview This report provides an evaluation of Climate Assembly UK (CAUK). This was a citizens’ assembly commissioned by six select committees from the House of Commons: Business Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS); Environmental Audit; Housing, Communities and Local Government, Science and Technology; Transport; and Treasury. It was tasked with providing recommendations on how … Continue reading Evaluation of Climate Assembly UK Stephen Elstub, David M. Farrell, Jayne Carrick and Patricia Mockler (2021)
Democracy is a tough way to live. With all its flaws, I think it beats the alternatives. I do not wish to have someone else, no matter how educated, well-intentioned, wealthy, or wise, decide unilaterally what is best for me. Unless we are deeply involved in our work, we cannot feel good about ourselves. Unless … Continue reading Democracy Is a Tough Way to Live Marvin Weisbord
Understanding our Political Nature: How to put knowledge and reason at the heart of political decision-making Abstract Recognising that advances in behavioural, decision and social sciences demonstrate that we are not purely rational beings, this report brings new insights into our political behaviour and this understanding have the potential to address some of the current … Continue reading Understanding Our Political Nature EU Science Hub (2019)
Values and Identities – a policymaker’s guide Abstract This report presents the state-of-the-art scientific knowledge on Values and Identities from an interdisciplinary perspective. Values are said to be the dominating forces in life and Identities represent who we are and to whom we belong. Both shape the political landscape in democracies and have gained in … Continue reading Values and Identities – a Policymaker’s Guide EU Science Hub (2021)
Gurteen Knowledge Blog July 22, 2022, 14:36You may enjoy these three talks by Rory Stewart from the BBC Radio 4 Seriously series of audio documentaries and podcasts. In the talks, Rory looks at the history of argument and explores its importance and the fact that it is the foundation of our democracies and how we make … Continue reading The Long History of Argument A series of talks by Rory Stewart
Technology and Democracy: Understanding the influence of online technologies on political behaviour and decision-making Abstract Drawing from many disciplines, the report adopts a behavioural psychology perspective to argue that “social media changes people’s political behaviour”. Four pressure points are identified and analysed in detail: the attention economy; choice architectures; algorithmic content curation; and mis/disinformation. Policy … Continue reading Technology and Democracy EU Science Hub (2020)
Polarisation vs Democracy | Matthew Taylor This conversation between Matthew Taylor and Rebel Wisdom’s David Fuller covers the destructive impact of new technology, how politics itself is based on bad faith argumentation, and how a cultural shift is needed to reverse course. Posts where this video is embedded Avoiding Modern-day Colonialism Colonialism: the dominance, control, and … Continue reading Polarisation Vs Democracy Matthew Taylor
Our society is dangerously polarised. We don’t listen to each other. Too many of us are separating into ideological tribes. This has to stop. The future of our democracy depends on it. This is what the Munk Debates is all about. Opening minds to different points of view. Challenging groupthink. Debating controversial issues with rigour … Continue reading Our Society Is Dangerously Polarised Munk Debates
Gurteen Knowledge Blog June 20, 2021, 14:50I blogged recently about the Consilience Project — co-founded by Daniel Schmachtenberger. The project team have now launched the Consilience Project website. The project aims to facilitate a cultural renaissance, developing the full human capacities and orientations needed for effective, emergent governance adequate to the novelty and scope of the … Continue reading Consilience Project Website Facilitating a cultural renaissance
Science is more than a body of knowledge; it is a way of thinking. I have a foreboding of an America in my children’s or grandchildren’s time — when the United States is a service and information economy; when nearly all the key manufacturing industries have slipped away to other countries; when awesome technological powers … Continue reading I Have a Foreboding Carl Sagan
video playerThe Future of Reasoning | Michael Stevens (Lottocracy) Posts where this video is embedded Avoiding Modern-day Colonialism Colonialism: the dominance, control, and exploitation by one group over another Conversation in Ancient Greek Society ** Socrates, Plato and Aristotle Deliberative Democracy ** Deliberation is central to decision-making Democracy’s Spectrum ** From Direct to Representative Enlightenment 2.0 A New Enlightenment for … Continue reading The Future of Reasoning Reason and logic are struggling
The liberal democracy is an artificial environment, carefully crafted to both contain human nature and convert it into an engine of progress. When we grow up within an artificial habitat that values human inventions like reason and fairness and humanity, it can be easy to forget just how tenuous that environment is. It’s easy to … Continue reading The Liberal Democracy Is an Artificial Environment Tim Urban
video player How to change your thinking with Daniel Schmachtenberger | Aubrey Marcus (Everyone believes they’re the good guy) Posts where this video is embedded Avoiding Modern-day Colonialism Colonialism: the dominance, control, and exploitation by one group over another Conversation in Ancient Greek Society ** Socrates, Plato and Aristotle Deliberative Democracy ** Deliberation is central to decision-making Democracy’s Spectrum … Continue reading How to Change Your Thinking with Daniel Schmachtenberger Aubrey Marcus
A primary object should be the education of our youth in the science of government. In a republic, what species of knowledge can be equally important? And what duty more pressing than communicating it to those who are to be the future guardians of the liberties of the country? Credit: George Washington Posts where this … Continue reading A Primary Object of Education Should Be the Science of Government George Washington
Gurteen Knowledge Blog October 2, 2022, 18:41I recently discovered Munk Debates and the Munk Debate website. They have some excellent debates, and I love their mission. Interestingly, they also have Munk Dialogues though I find them a little disappointing as they are not dialogues (conversations between equals) but soft interviews – in other words, the interviewer … Continue reading Munk Debates and Dialogues Excellent debates and dialogues
Tolerance Is A Social Contract, Not a Moral Absolute Evolution of Democracy ** Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter Democracy is a system of government where the power lies with the people. In a democracy, citizens exercise their power through voting in elections to choose their leaders and representatives. All votes are equal, and … Continue reading Democracy’s Spectrum ** From Direct to Representative
Democracy’s Spectrum ** Socrates on Democracy Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter Democracy has a rich and complex history that dates back to ancient civilizations. The term itself originates from the Greek words “demos” (people) and “kratos” (power), reflecting its foundational principle of people’s rule. The most celebrated early example of a democratic system … Continue reading Evolution of Democracy **
Evolution of Democracy ** Modern Democracy ** Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter Democracy’s theoretical ideals clash with citizens’ limited expertise; the loudest voices often prevail over the wisest. Socrates proposed a balanced approach – civic education to cultivate wisdom alongside expert policy guidance to strengthen democratic governance. Socrates was one of the most … Continue reading Socrates on Democracy Socrates had a nuanced view of democracy
Socrates on Democracy Voting in a Democracy ** Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter Socrates’ view on democracy, which emphasized the need for education and wise decision-making, resonates profoundly in modern democratic societies. Today, the challenges he identified — such as the potential for mob rule, the importance of balancing freedom with law and … Continue reading Modern Democracy **
Modern Democracy ** Deliberative Democracy ** Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter Voting in a democracy is the fundamental process through which citizens participate in their government’s decision-making. It has various advantages and disadvantages. … Continue reading Voting in a Democracy **
Voting in a Democracy ** Freedom of Speech Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter Citizens, Assemble! Deliberative Democracy in 3 Minutes What is Deliberative Democracy? When Citizens Assemble Posts that link to this post Social Reasoning The Argumentative Theory of Human Reason The Argumentative Theory of Human Reason We did not evolve to reason individually but … Continue reading Deliberative Democracy ** Deliberation is central to decision-making
Knowledge and Information ** The Knowledge Delusion Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter The argumentative theory of reasoning proposes that reason did not evolve to help us to reason individually but to reason together – in other words, socially. Reasoning is generally seen as the process of thinking about something to help us come … Continue reading The Argumentative Theory of Human Reason We did not evolve to reason individually but to reason socially
The Extended Mind Rethinking Our Beliefs Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter Polarization of opinions is becoming more prevalent in today’s society and is creating both unrest at the societal level as well as conflict within small groups with different views. We are polarized across political, religious, moral, and racial divides. We fail to … Continue reading Opinion Polarization We are polarized across political, religious, moral, and racial divides
Tribal Thinking Discrediting People ** Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter Motivated reasoning is where we look for arguments in favor of conclusions we want to believe, regardless of the evidence. This is a primary stumbling block in forming sound beliefs and making good decisions. However, if we are science-curious, we are more likely … Continue reading Science Curiosity A desire to seek out and consume scientific information for pleasure
Psychological Safety ** Introduction: Small Group Conversations Close Pop-up all posts in this chapter The wisdom of crowds is the concept that large groups of people are collectively smarter than individuals regarding problem-solving, decision-making, and predicting. However, the method can be improved with the wisdom of crowds of crowds. In the concept of the wisdom … Continue reading Wisdom of Crowds of Crowds Crowds within a crowd outperform ‘wisdom of the crowd’