We often use words like thinking, reasoning, and cognition interchangeably, but they refer to different layers of how we engage with the world internally. Drawing clear distinctions between them helps us become more aware of how we process information, make decisions, and navigate complexity.
Cognition: The Broad Landscape
Cognition is the most encompassing of the three. It refers to all the mental processes involved in acquiring, processing, storing, and using information. This includes everything from perceiving and remembering to understanding language, solving problems, and making decisions.
In short: cognition is the full architecture of mental life.
It includes both conscious and unconscious processes. Whether you’re recognizing a familiar face, recalling a fact, focusing your attention, or forming a new idea, you’re engaging in cognitive activity.
Common cognitive functions include:
– Perception (how we take in and interpret sensory information)
– Attention (what we focus on)
– Memory (what we retain and recall)
– Language (how we understand and express meaning)
– Learning (how we adapt based on experience)
Within this broad landscape, thinking occupies a distinct and important space.
Thinking: The Deliberate Activity of the Mind
Thinking is a subset of cognition. It is what we often mean when we talk about being “in our heads.” It is the mental activity of working with information such as recalling, imagining, planning, evaluating, and wondering.
Not all cognition is thinking. For example, you might perceive a red light and stop your car automatically. That is cognition without deliberate thought. But if you begin wondering why that intersection always feels unsafe, or how traffic patterns might be improved, that is thinking.
Thinking can be:
– Reflective (mulling something over)
– Imaginative (dreaming up possibilities)
– Intuitive (quick, gut-feeling responses)
– Strategic (weighing options, planning ahead)
In short: thinking is cognition with intention, a focused use of the mind’s resources.
Reasoning: The Structured Path Within Thinking
Reasoning is even more specific. It is a form of thinking with a particular purpose: to draw conclusions, make inferences, solve problems, or justify decisions. It relies on some kind of logic, whether formal or informal.
Where thinking might wander or associate freely, reasoning has direction. It is guided by evidence, arguments, and often a need for coherence.
Types of reasoning include:
– Deductive (from general rules to specific conclusions)
– Inductive (from specific cases to general patterns)
– Abductive (inferring the best explanation)
For example:
– Thinking might be: “I remember hearing about climate change and I wonder what it means for my city.”
– Reasoning might be: “If sea levels are rising, and my city is coastal, then it is likely to face more flooding. Therefore, we might need to rethink infrastructure planning.”
In short: reasoning is structured thinking in the service of drawing conclusions.
Nested and Interconnected
We can think of these terms as nested layers:
– Cognition is the broadest, including all mental processes.
– Thinking is a deliberate form of cognition.
– Reasoning is a structured and goal-directed form of thinking.
They are not fixed categories. In everyday life, we shift fluidly between them. A passing thought may lead to reflection, which becomes structured reasoning, which then fades into daydreaming. The boundaries are soft.
But understanding these distinctions helps clarify how we engage with the world internally and externally. It also opens up a more precise vocabulary for conversation, leadership, learning, and decision-making.
Why This Distinction Matters
In a world increasingly shaped by artificial intelligence, understanding the nuances of our own mental activity is not just philosophical, it is practical.
AI systems can mimic certain kinds of reasoning. They can process information, solve problems, even simulate forms of thinking. But they do not feel, reflect, or perceive in the human sense. They do not have the full landscape of cognition.
By sharpening our understanding of terms like thinking, reasoning, and cognition, we equip ourselves to ask better questions, not just of machines but of ourselves.
We begin to notice how we think, not just what we think.
And that is where deeper insight begins.
Posts tagged with: thinking, cognition, reasoning
Posts
- Artificial Intelligence and the Quest for Knowledge (Artificial Intelligence)
Exploring the parallels between Plato's Phaedrus and the challenges of GenAI - Avoiding Modern-day Colonialism (Appendix)
Colonialism: the dominance, control, and exploitation by one group over another - Beyond the Brain (Neuroscience of Conversation)
The multidimensional nature of cognition - Chatbots as Critical Thinking Partners (Chatbots as Critical Thinking Partners)
Stimulating critical thinking is one of the most powerful application of chatbots - Critical Thinking ** (Conversational Leadership Skills)
Analyzing information and arguments to make sound judgments and decisions - Dialectical Thinking (Thinking Together)
Practicing dialectical thinking in complex times - Entrenched Thinking ** (Thinking Together)
The lack of desire or ability to accept new ideas - Friends with Cognitive Benefits (The Power of Conversation)
Engaging in short friendly conversations improves people's thinking - Gurteen Knowledge Café: Entrenched and Entrained Thinking (Knowledge Café Stories)
A blog post by Conrad Taylor - Introduction: Thinking Together (Thinking Together)
Cognition, thinking and reasoning - Motivated Reasoning ** (Thinking Together)
Leads people to confirm what they already believe, while ignoring contrary data - Oracy (The Power of Conversation)
The ability to express oneself in and understand spoken language - The Argumentative Theory of Human Reason (Thinking Together)
We did not evolve to reason individually but to reason socially - The Enlightenment (We Live in Two Worlds)
The Age of Reason - The Extended Mind (Thinking Together)
The power of distributed cognition - The Importance of Tacit Knowledge (Knowledge Management)
Tacit knowledge is knowledge that is difficult to transfer - Think Together (Conversational Leadership Practice Areas)
A Conversational Leadership Practice Area - Three Forms of Reasoning (Thinking Together)
Understanding deductive, inductive, and abductive logic - Understanding 4E Cognition (Neuroscience of Conversation)
The multidimensional nature of cognition - Ways of Knowing (Knowledge Management)
Ways of acquiring knowledge - What Are Cognitive Biases? (Thinking Together)
Mistakes in reasoning, evaluating or remembering
Books
- Closing the Mind Gap: Making Smarter Decisions in a Hypercomplex World
by Ted Cadsby (2014) - Conflicted: Why Arguments Are Tearing Us Apart and How They Can Bring Us Together
by Ian Leslie (2021) - Enlightenment 2.0: Restoring Sanity to Our Politics, Our Economy, and Our Lives
by Joseph Heath (2014) - Enlightenment Now: the Case for Reason, Science, Humanism, and Progress
by Steven Pinker (2019) - Hard to Be Human: Overcoming Our Five Cognitive Design Flaws
by Ted Cadsby (2021) - Interthinking: Putting Talk to Work
by Karen Littleton, Neil Mercer (2013) - Rationality: What It Is, Why It Seems Scarce, Why It Matters
by Steven Pinker (2021) - Rebel Ideas: the Power of Diverse Thinking
by Matthew Syed (2019) - Scout Mindset: Why Some People See Things Clearly and Others Don’t
by Julia Galef (2021) - The Enigma of Reason: A New Theory of Human Understanding
by Dan Sperber and Hugo Mercier (2018) - The Knowledge Illusion: Why We Never Think Alone
by Steven Sloman and Philip Fernbach (2018) - The Righteous Mind: Why Good People Are Divided by Politics and Religion
by Jonathan Haidt (2013) - Think Again: the Power of Knowing What You Don’t Know
by Adam Grant (2021) - Time to Think: Listening to Ignite the Human Mind
by Nancy Kline
People
- Julia Galef
Writer and public speaker - Matthew Syed
Journalist, author and broadcaster
Videos
- How and Why We Reason
Hugo Mercier (2015) - The Argumentative Theory of Human Reason
Reasoning was designed by evolution to help us win arguments - The Future of Reasoning
Michael Stevens - Why Do We Believe Things That Aren’t True?
Philip Fernbach (2017)
Quotations
- A Man Is What He Thinks About All Day Long
Ralph Waldo Emerson - Abercrombie’s Thesis
Melanie Abercrombie - Beginning to Think in a New Way
Ludwig Wittgenstein - Being Profoundly Interested in What You Think
Nancy Kline - Bertrand Russell’s Ten Commandments for Critical Thinking
Bertrand Russell - Connecting Beliefs and Evidence
David T. Moore - Conversation Is the Vehicle for Change
Terry Tempest Williams - Emptying Assumptions
Hannah Arendt - If You’re Thinking Without Writing, You Only Think You’re Thinking
Leslie Lamport - In Order to Be Able to Think, You Have to Risk Being Offensive
Jordan B. Peterson - Intellectual Humility
Greg Lukianoff & Jonathan Haidt - It Has Been Said That Man Is a Rational Animal
Bertrand Russell - It Is in Speaking That We Organize Cognitively What We Know
David W. Johnson and Roger T. Johnson - Man Is Not a Rational Animal; He Is a Rationalizing Animal
Robert Heinlein - Men Will Believe What They See. Let Them See
Henry David Thoreau - Moral Reasoning Is Generally Done Post-hoc
Jonathan Haidt - Our Beliefs Are Not Isolated Pieces of Data That We Can Take and Discard at Will
Steven Sloman - Our Beliefs Are Not Properly Shaped by Healthy Scrutiny and Debate
Thomas Gilovich - Our Spoken Language Enables Us to Think Together
David Gurteen - People Mistakenly Assume That Their Thinking Is Done by Their Head
Anthony de Mello - Power of Questions
Neil Postman - Productive Disagreement Depends on How People Feel About Each Other
Ian Leslie - Reason Is, and Ought Only to Be the Slave of the Passions
David Hume (1739) - Risk of Independent Thought
Christopher Hitchens - Teaching Critical Thinking Alone Is Not a Solution to Helping People Question Their Beliefs
David Gurteen - The Best Way to Gauge the Quality of Someone’s Ideas
Adam Grant (2024) - The Book Medium Is a Stronger Message Than Its Content
Marshall McLuhan - The Sciences of Complexity Change Our Perspective and Thinking
Esko Kilpi - Thinking and Spoken Discourse
Plato - Thinking Differently
David Bohm - Thinking Is Dangerous
Hannah Arendt - Treating Governance Like Scientific Experimentation
Steven Pinker - Using Talk to Reason Together
Neil Mercer - We Are Drowning in Information, While Starving for Wisdom
E. O. Wilson - We Are Moving Into a New Period of Human Consciousness
Henry Kissinger - We Have Not Touched the Deeper Causes of Our Troubles
David Bohm - We Need to Start Talking and Listening
Jordan Peterson - What Is Street Epistemology?
Anthony Magnabosco - What Is the Root Cause of the Major Problems in the World?
Gregory Bateson - When Dealing with People, We Are Not Dealing with Creatures of Logic
Dale Carnegie - When Minds Meet
Theodore Zeldin - Writing as Thinking
George Orwell - Writing, Thinking, Conversing—a Cycle of Insight
David Gurteen - You Have to Use Writing to Help Yourself Do Your Thinking
Larry McEnerney
Papers
- Friends (and Sometimes Enemies) with Cognitive Benefits: What Types of Social Interactions Boost Executive Functioning?
Oscar Ybarra, Piotr Winkielman, Irene Yeh, Eugene Burnstein, Liam Kavanagh (2011) - Why Do Humans Reason? Arguments for an Argumentative Theory
Hugo Mercier and Dan Sperber (2010)
Blog Posts
- Anyone Who Values Truth Should Stop Worshiping Reason
The Righteous Mind - Beyond Information Sharing
The collaborative nature of conversation - Carl Sagan’s Foreboding on the Future of America in 1995
Science is more than a body of knowledge; it is a way of thinking - Chatbots as an Aid to Critical Thinking
Reasoning and decision-making - Engaging in Short Friendly Conversations Improves People’s Thinking
Friends with Cognitive Benefits - Lesswrong: Aiming to Be Less Wrong About the World Than the Day Before
Improving human reasoning and decision-making - Social Reasoning
The Argumentative Theory of Human Reason - The Courage to Think in Public
Speaking before your thoughts are fully formed - The Four Pillars of Cognition
Embodiment, Embeddedness, Extension, and Enaction - The Shaky Ground Beneath Our Beliefs
Questioning our beliefs - The Value of a Contrarian Thinker
They help you question your beliefs - Two Interesting Theories of Reason
Social reasoning and the narrative paradigm
Resources
- Embodied Cognition
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (2021)
Detailed Resources
- Article: Embodied Cognition by Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (2021)
POST NAVIGATION
CHAPTER NAVIGATION
SEARCH
Blook SearchGoogle Web Search
Photo Credits: DALL-E (Public Domain)
Wednesday 11th March 2026, 14:00 to 18:00 London time (GMT)
Learn how to design & run a Gurteen Knowledge Café, both face-to-face and online.
Information and Registration